Skip to content
SAICA Events
Home
Home
SAICA – ANNUAL COUNCIL EVALUATION – 2026
You are here:
Home
SAICA – ANNUAL COUNCIL EVALUATION…
SAICA – ANNUAL COUNCIL EVALUATION – 2026
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
INTRODUCTION
This annual evaluation is intended to assess the effectiveness of the SAICA Council in discharging its advisory and consultative mandate in accordance with the SAICA Constitution, the SAICA By-laws and the Council Charter. The evaluation also considers relevant governance principles contained in King V, including ethical and effective leadership, stakeholder inclusivity, performance, conformance and legitimacy. The purpose of the evaluation is to support continuous improvement in Council’s contribution to SAICA, the Board, Members, Associates and the profession, while maintaining appropriate role clarity between the Council as an advisory body and the Board as the governing body of SAICA. CONTEXT SAICA is a voluntary not-for-profit organisation that operates in terms of its Constitution, for its members. Its primary source of revenue are membership fees, fees from seminars and events, as well as donor funding. SAICA is the custodian of three complementary accounting designations, CA (SA), AGA (SA) and AT (SA) globally.
Leadership and Ethics
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3.
The Council exercises ethical and effective leadership within its advisory and consultative mandate, and contributes to ethical culture, performance, conformance and legitimacy in line with King V.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
There is sound tone at the top/ an ethical culture / “doing the right thing” / An embedded rather than a compliance driven approach.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
The Council contributes to the Institute’s values.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Recommend changes to the Code of Professional Conduct for approval by the Board
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council understands the exceptional circumstances under which it may temporarily assume Board powers if the majority of Board members resign or are removed and are not replaced in accordance with the Constitution and By-laws.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Responsible corporate citizen, stakeholders, sustainability and corporate responsibility
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
The Council properly fulfils its role in regard to stakeholders (who they are and how needs are met).
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
The Council maintains effective communication with its stakeholders, including Regional Councils, interest groups, Members and Associates.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Reputation management is always taken into account.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council identifies new Interest Groups and recommend these to the Board for representation on the Council.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council advises the Board on the award of honorary life membership to Members.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council effectively represent Members’ and Associates’ interests facilitated through input from the Regional Councils and other relevant sources.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council members balance constituency perspectives with their duty to act in the interests of SAICA as a whole.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council receives sufficient and timely input from Regional Councils, interest groups and other relevant sources to represent Members’ and Associates’ interests effectively.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Feedback loops from Council to Regional Councils, interest groups and other stakeholders are effective.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Strategy and business performance
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
The Council provides meaningful input to the Board on SAICA’s long-term strategy and matters affecting the profession, while recognising that responsibility for approving and overseeing strategy rests with the Board.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
The Council ensures that relevant stakeholders, including Members, are updated on the implementation of the strategy and other significant issues.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
The Council appreciates that strategy, risk, performance and sustainability are inseparable and give effect to this by contributing to the strategy of the Institute, including its short, medium and long-term strategic direction;
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Council Dynamics
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
Appropriate balance of skills, experience, gender, race and diversity.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
1.1 Council Composition
Council members are properly prepared and make meaningful input.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
1.2 Council Contributions
The Council constructively engages difficult matters with the CEO and Board and appropriately raises concerns where the Board may be operating outside its constitutional mandate.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Discussions are open and frank. Not dominated by any one individual or group.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
1.3 COUNCIL Climate
The frequency of Council meetings is appropriate to enable Council to discharge its advisory and consultative mandate effectively, including the ability to convene additional meetings where reasonably required.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
The content and quality of agendas/papers and information provided to the COUNCIL is at the right level.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
The Council Charter is adequate and appropriate to enable the key role and functions of the COUNCIL to be effectively performed and discharged.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council minutes are accurate, sufficiently detailed, circulated timeously and properly record key deliberations, decisions and recommendations.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council has adequate resourcing to deliver its mandate.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
How do you rate the turn-around time on reimbursements of payments to council members.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Are the region or constituent levels adequately resourced to champion the work of Council.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Evaluation of performance
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
The Council ensures that the evaluation of its own performance support continued improvement in its performance and effectiveness.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Succession
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
The Council properly fulfils its role with regards to succession.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Are the current succession requirements for Council members appropriate.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Succession of members and key roles within the Council (President) is reviewed annually. Appointment follows a proper process.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Induction / orientation and member development is provided.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Governance – The Council:
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
Council considers whether its own Charter, composition, processes and contribution remain appropriate in light of governance developments, King V expectations and SAICA’s evolving context.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Ensures that members are equitably treated, and ensure that disputes are resolved as effectively, efficiently and expeditiously as possible.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Council operates within its advisory and consultative mandate and does not interfere with the activities of the Board, except where constitutional escalation to Members is required.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Other
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
Successes of the Council over past year.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Shortfalls of the Council over the past year.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Key challenges facing the Council in the year ahead.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
Themes for specific roles
Council President
1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3
Provides effective leadership. Fair treatment of Council members. Clear role between chairman and CEO. Allows for proper debate and conducts meetings effectively.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Provide effective leadership at Council level.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Provide proper report back to the Council.
Rate 1 out of 5
Rate 2 out of 5
Rate 3 out of 5
Rate 4 out of 5
Rate 5 out of 5
Comment
METHODOLOGY
The evaluation for the council collectively is in the form of a questionnaire (attached. The questionnaire requires one of the following responses in respect of each question, using the rating scale below. Rating scale: 1 = Poor; 2 = Needs improvement; 3 = Satisfactory; 4 = Good; 5 = Outstanding. Comments should be provided for all ratings, and improvement actions should be proposed for any rating of 1, 2 or 3. Where a rating indicates a development area, Council members should identify the relevant issue, the recommended improvement, and any support required to strengthen Council’s effectiveness and alignment with its constitutional and charter mandate.
OUTCOMES OF THE EVALUATION
The evaluation results will be consolidated and analysed to identify key strengths, areas for improvement and recurring themes. Matters requiring action will be captured in an improvement plan indicating the relevant action, accountable owner, expected timeframe and progress status. The consolidated outcomes and proposed improvement plan will be tabled with Council and, where appropriate, communicated to the Board to support alignment between Council’s advisory role and the Board’s governance responsibilities. The outcomes of the evaluation will enable the council to: ▪ determine whether or not it has delivered on its mandate; ▪ measure and where possible, enhance, both the council’s overall efficiency; and ▪ identify areas for possible improvement.
Submit
Go to Top